Log In
Sign Up and Get Started Blogging!
JoeUser is completely free to use! By Signing Up on JoeUser, you can create your own blog and participate on the blogs of others!
The Hampster of doom
Nonsense and other sillyness...
Adobe Photoshop vs. Corel Photopaint
Published on December 13, 2001 By
John Hamp
In
WinCustomize Talk
What is the best graphics package for making skins would you say? I currently have Corel Photopaint 10 but am thinking of purchasing Photoshop 6. Anyone out there have experience with both?
Popular Articles in this Category
Happy Birthday, Red!
October 2024 Desktop Screenshots
November 2024 Desktop Screenshots
Popular Articles from John Hamp
Rise of Legends: Case study in multiplayer
Comments
1
Grog
on Dec 14, 2001
Unless your made of Money, stick with Photopaint 10, or go for Paint Shop Pro 7 which is only 79 dollars US. Heck for that matter you could use Gimp which is Free.
2
DavidK
on Dec 14, 2001
Photoshop doesn't really add anything that Photopaint can't do. If you also have Corel Draw10 then you're all set. Use the drawiing tools in Draw and export the result to Photopaint. It's not much different than using Illustrator and Photoshop...
3
AJCrowley
on Dec 14, 2001
I'd personally say go with Photoshop if you can. I could be considered biased though, since I've been using Photoshop for so long. I also use Paint Shop Pro, but imho after version 5, it stopped being a rich man's Paintbrush, and started being a poor man's Photoshop.
4
paxx
on Dec 14, 2001
No, really, Photopaint is just as good as Photoshop, althoughPhotoshop is the standard in the industry. So, unless you're looking to get hired in a production company - then you need to know Photoshop or nobody will hire you - then you'd be waisting your money. I'm not saying Photoshop isn't good, no no, it's excellent, but Corel's graphics suite is just as good, it's just not as popular. I know some people who will even argue that Corel is actually better.
5
Frogboy
on Dec 16, 2001
I've been using Photopaint since it started being included with Corel Draw. I now have Photopaint 10 and I must say I'm quite disappointed that Photoshop 6 has surpassed it.
Photopaint has always had a better UI for many things, it takes fewer steps for many common tasks.
But Photopaint has fallen behind in some pretty basic stuff such as being able to do quick effects to "objects" (the Corel equivalent of Layers).
In Photoshop, I can select a layer and choose blending options and features such as bevel, drop shadow, glows, etc. are all right there.
In Photopaint, by contrast, those features either don't exist or are pathetically poor and require far more steps. Take Beveling, for instance, the Photopaint version of Bevel and emboss is basically broken. It's just so much quicker to apply quick effects to a layer in Photoshop that do what 99% of users would want that it overshadows for me, the nice things in Photopaint's UI.
And Photopaint is rather buggy. Ctrl-Insert, a CUA convention, works but Shift-Insert will cause the Marque feature to go into "Add" mode and only a literal mouse click on the UI will change it back, very annoying.
6
LancerKMT
on Jan 04, 2002
the Photoshop work mothodology is professional, thats why people who has desing studies prefer it; of course anyone can use it. Photopaint is for amateurs.
7
jtfolden
on Jan 04, 2002
Has anyone tried Painter 7 for Windows? I use this under Mac OS X now and wouldn't trade it for anything else. I have no idea how the Win version stacks up, though. I'm wondering if Corel hasn't reduced it's efforts in the area of Photopaint 10 (which I also find lacking under OS X) in order to put all it's eggs under the Painter 7 basket. P7 might be overkill for those used to Photpaint.
8
deadman67
on Jan 04, 2002
i,m using Corel Photopaint 10,adobe photoshop6,Ulead photoimpact6,paint shop pro and zoner draw3.
it may seem alot of programs but each can be handy to have.
Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums.
Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
It's simple, and FREE!
Sign Up Now!
Meta
Views
» 3024
Comments
»
8
Category
»
WinCustomize Talk
Comment
Recent Article Comments
A day in the Life of Odditie...
Safe and free software downl...
LightStar Design Windowblind...
Veterans Day
Let's start a New Jammin Thr...
A new and more functional PC...
Post your joy
Let's see your political mem...
AI Art Thread: 2022
WD Black Internal and Extern...
Sponsored Links